Good Scene / Bad Scene
Chosen by Joe Russo, the co-director of 'Welcome To Collinwood', to be released on 25 april
Good: 'Shoot the Piano Player' (François Truffaut, 1960)
Good: 'Shoot the Piano Player' (François Truffaut, 1960)
This scene encapsulates the nouvelle vague – its imagination and experimentation. It's when the piano-player's brother visits him at the bar where he works, and there's a series of absurd moments that aim to explain what the film's about – the relationship between the sexes. There's a jazz singer who sings a hilarious, non-rhythmic song about men and women. There's a woman who keeps on seductively pulling a man towards her, then pushing him away, until the man slaps her and a brawl breaks out. And, through all this madness, the piano player continues on. The scene marries poignant insight with absurdism.
Bad: 'The Best Years of Our Lives' (William Wyler, 1946)
The opening scene is a good example of the terrible melodrama so prevalent in post-WWII cinema. The scene sets up the plot of how three Second World War veterans (above) meet on a plane going home, and how they adjust to civilian life. There's a shot when one of them has to sign a paper, and he takes his hands out of his pockets to reveal that they are hooks – they've been blown off. The other servicemen react by gawping. It's so unsubtle, I was turned off in the first 15 minutes.
Subscribe to Independent Premium to bookmark this article
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies